The State Quarters Program was a major coin series released by the United States Mint from 1999 to 2008.
This collection honored all 50 U.S. states, each with its own distinct design, making the coins popular among collectors. While most of these quarters are only worth their face value, a few stand out due to rare minting mistakes, low mintage, or unusual features — and those can be worth a small fortune.
Whether you’re a dedicated numismatist or someone curious about spare change, this guide highlights five state quarters that are still circulating and could be worth over $5,000 each.
1. 1999 Delaware Quarter (Doubled Die Obverse)
One of the most famous error coins, the 1999 Delaware quarter, contains a doubled die on the obverse. This means certain features of George Washington’s face appear duplicated due to a misaligned die during minting.
Collectors prize this error, especially when the doubling is clearly visible on areas like the cheek, lips, and nose.
Value: Depending on how clear the doubling is and the coin’s condition, it may be valued up to $6,000.
2. 2004 Wisconsin Quarter (Extra Leaf)
The 2004 Wisconsin quarter is highly collectible thanks to an unusual error — an additional leaf near the ear of corn on the reverse. Originally released with a standard design, a flaw during minting led to some coins showing an “extra leaf” on the corn stalk.
Collectors eagerly seek both the “low leaf” and “high leaf” varieties.
Value: In well-preserved condition, this quarter can sell for as much as $5,000, especially if the error is sharply defined.
3. 2005 Minnesota Quarter (In God We Rust)
This Minnesota quarter earned the nickname “In God We Rust” due to a die obstruction error that caused part of the motto “In God We Trust” to be obscured. The resulting appearance — “In God We Rust” — makes it an unusual and desirable find.
This kind of debris-caused minting flaw is rare and noticeable to those who check their change carefully.
Value: Perfect examples of this error can command prices up to $7,000, particularly if the coin is in mint state.
4. 2004 Michigan Quarter (Full Torch)
Though part of the Great Lakes series, the 2004 Michigan quarter is most valuable when it shows a full and distinct torch design. Some quarters have faint or incomplete torch imprints, but those with a bold and complete torch are far rarer.
Collectors look for coins where every element of the torch is sharply defined.
Value: When well-preserved and featuring the full torch design, this coin can be worth up to $5,000.
5. 2000 South Carolina Quarter (Inverted “S” Mint Mark)
From the early wave of state quarters, the 2000 South Carolina version includes a unique error — an upside-down “S” mint mark. This type of misprint is extremely rare, as mint marks are typically applied with great precision.
An inverted mint mark dramatically increases a coin’s desirability among collectors.
Value: A South Carolina quarter featuring this error can sell for $5,500 or more depending on condition.
Top 5 State Quarters Worth Over $5,000
| Quarter Name | Year | Error Type | Estimated Value | Condition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Delaware Quarter | 1999 | Doubled Die Obverse | Up to $6,000 | High-quality examples |
| Wisconsin Quarter | 2004 | Extra Leaf | Up to $5,000 | High-quality examples |
| Minnesota Quarter | 2005 | In God We Rust | Up to $7,000 | Excellent condition |
| Michigan Quarter | 2004 | Full Torch | Up to $5,000 | Full, visible torch |
| South Carolina Quarter | 2000 | Inverted “S” Mint Mark | Up to $5,500 | Well-preserved |
How to Spot These Rare Quarters
To locate these valuable coins, closely examine your quarters under a bright light or with a magnifying glass. Look for specific details like:
- Delaware Quarter: Focus on Washington’s face to spot the doubled features.
- Wisconsin Quarter: Check the corn stalk for an extra leaf.
- Minnesota Quarter: Inspect the inscription “In God We Trust” for fading or obstruction.
- Michigan Quarter: Ensure the torch is fully present and not faint.
- South Carolina Quarter: Look at the mint mark; if the “S” is upside down, you may have a rare piece.
If you think you’ve found one of these valuable coins, it’s best to consult a professional coin grader or numismatist for proper evaluation.
Most state quarters will remain worth just 25 cents, but a select few with rare traits continue to circulate — and they could be worth thousands. Always check your change; you might stumble upon a small treasure without even knowing it.
FAQs
How do I know if I have a valuable state quarter?
Look carefully for unique mint errors like doubled images, extra leaves, or inverted mint marks. Use a magnifying glass for the best results.
Can I sell my valuable quarters?
Yes, rare quarters can be sold to coin dealers or auctioned. It’s smart to have them appraised by an expert beforehand.
What is the best way to preserve rare state quarters?
Store them in coin holders or protective cases. Avoid frequent handling to keep them in top condition.
Where can I get my coin evaluated?
You can visit a certified numismatist, attend coin shows, or use grading services like PCGS or NGC for a professional opinion.
Matthew K. Ayers is a seasoned finance writer with a sharp eye for market trends and economic insights. With a background in financial analysis and a passion for simplifying complex topics, he crafts clear, actionable content to help readers make smarter money decisions. From personal finance to global markets, Matthew delivers trustworthy advice with clarity and precision.
